Categories
Home/Engineering/An engineer who has taken a new job with a competitor of the previous company meets a research engineer who describes her plans for developing a new product similar to one developed by the former company. He knows that the direction this engineer is taking will lead to a dead end and will cost the company a lot of time and money. Should he tell her what he knows? Does the answer to this question change if the new company is not a direct competitor of the previous one?

An engineer who has taken a new job with a competitor of the previous company meets a research engineer who describes her plans for developing a new product similar to one developed by the former company. He knows that the direction this engineer is taking will lead to a dead end and will cost the company a lot of time and money. Should he tell her what he knows? Does the answer to this question change if the new company is not a direct competitor of the previous one?

Synopsis of the issue

Ethics is about what is right and what is wrong. Different ethical theories provide different approaches to dealing with ethical situations that arise.

Issues

The situation at giving rise to the problem is how to determine if the act is right or wrong of informing the researcher engineer about the previous failure to develop the new product. From an ethical perspective, it is completely right to tell her of the unanticipated dead end.

Ethical theories

By basing the argument on the utilitarian theory, it will be right because an action can only be right depending on the result of the action. In addition, the engineer was learning new skills and acquiring new knowledge, which constituted part of his professional development. The engineer owns the knowledge and skills developed in the previous station, and his act of telling the research engineer about the dead-end reached in developing the new product was right. Watching the project progress without informing them of the previous failures could be unethical. The engineer is bound to obey the dictates of reason and is bound to act morally based on the principle of moral behavior and the logical contradictions that allow the engineer to behave in a certain way.

The answer does not change if the new company is not a competitor. The ethical theory of consequentialism asserts that right depends on consequences. In addition, the theory of ethical utilitarianism affirms that right or wrong is judged by the outcome of an action.

Recommendation

The action of informing the new employers could save them a lot of money.

Rate the answer:
Views: 86
Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in engineering. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2021) 'An engineer who has taken a new job with a competitor of the previous company meets a research engineer who describes her plans for developing a new product similar to one developed by the former company. He knows that the direction this engineer is taking will lead to a dead end and will cost the company a lot of time and money. Should he tell her what he knows? Does the answer to this question change if the new company is not a direct competitor of the previous one'. 7 July.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2021, July 7). An engineer who has taken a new job with a competitor of the previous company meets a research engineer who describes her plans for developing a new product similar to one developed by the former company. He knows that the direction this engineer is taking will lead to a dead end and will cost the company a lot of time and money. Should he tell her what he knows? Does the answer to this question change if the new company is not a direct competitor of the previous one? https://academic.tips/question/an-engineer-who-has-taken-a-new-job-with-a-competitor-of-the-previous-company-meets-a-research-engineer-who-describes-her-plans-for-developing-a-new-product-similar-to-one-developed-by-the-former-comp/

References

Academic.Tips. 2021. "An engineer who has taken a new job with a competitor of the previous company meets a research engineer who describes her plans for developing a new product similar to one developed by the former company. He knows that the direction this engineer is taking will lead to a dead end and will cost the company a lot of time and money. Should he tell her what he knows? Does the answer to this question change if the new company is not a direct competitor of the previous one?" July 7, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/an-engineer-who-has-taken-a-new-job-with-a-competitor-of-the-previous-company-meets-a-research-engineer-who-describes-her-plans-for-developing-a-new-product-similar-to-one-developed-by-the-former-comp/.

1. Academic.Tips. "An engineer who has taken a new job with a competitor of the previous company meets a research engineer who describes her plans for developing a new product similar to one developed by the former company. He knows that the direction this engineer is taking will lead to a dead end and will cost the company a lot of time and money. Should he tell her what he knows? Does the answer to this question change if the new company is not a direct competitor of the previous one?" July 7, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/an-engineer-who-has-taken-a-new-job-with-a-competitor-of-the-previous-company-meets-a-research-engineer-who-describes-her-plans-for-developing-a-new-product-similar-to-one-developed-by-the-former-comp/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "An engineer who has taken a new job with a competitor of the previous company meets a research engineer who describes her plans for developing a new product similar to one developed by the former company. He knows that the direction this engineer is taking will lead to a dead end and will cost the company a lot of time and money. Should he tell her what he knows? Does the answer to this question change if the new company is not a direct competitor of the previous one?" July 7, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/an-engineer-who-has-taken-a-new-job-with-a-competitor-of-the-previous-company-meets-a-research-engineer-who-describes-her-plans-for-developing-a-new-product-similar-to-one-developed-by-the-former-comp/.

Work Cited

"An engineer who has taken a new job with a competitor of the previous company meets a research engineer who describes her plans for developing a new product similar to one developed by the former company. He knows that the direction this engineer is taking will lead to a dead end and will cost the company a lot of time and money. Should he tell her what he knows? Does the answer to this question change if the new company is not a direct competitor of the previous one?" Academic.Tips, 7 July 2021, academic.tips/question/an-engineer-who-has-taken-a-new-job-with-a-competitor-of-the-previous-company-meets-a-research-engineer-who-describes-her-plans-for-developing-a-new-product-similar-to-one-developed-by-the-former-comp/.

Copy
An engineer leaves a company and goes to work for a competitor. a. Is it ethical for the engineer to try to lure customers away from the previous employer? b. Is it alright for the engineer to use proprietary knowledge gained while working for the previous employer at the new job? How would the answer to this question change if the new job weren’t for the competitor? c. At a new job, is it acceptable to use skills developed during your previous employment?
What is a historical example of an engineering project that you believe was extremely risky but the benefits outweighed the risk? What is a historical example of a project that was undertaken were the risk ultimately did not outweigh the benefits?
Check the price of your paper