The criticism considering utilitarianism as a philosophical theory as a doctrine worthy only of swine’ might be explained as utilitarianists’ misleading tendency to limit human desires to the most primitive ones, such as pleasure. As a result, if a person has the same willingness as an animal, such as swine, then there is no sense in philosophy and consideration of the human role in world development.
In chapter 1 on page 12 of “The Ethical Life,” Mill says that utilitarianism has often been criticized by calling it “a doctrine worthy only of swine.” Explain the meaning of this criticism.
Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in philosophy. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.
Cite this page
Select a citation style:
References
Academic.Tips. (2023) 'In chapter 1 on page 12 of “The Ethical Life,” Mill says that utilitarianism has often been criticized by calling it "a doctrine worthy only of swine." Explain the meaning of this criticism'. 12 February.
Reference
Academic.Tips. (2023, February 12). In chapter 1 on page 12 of “The Ethical Life,” Mill says that utilitarianism has often been criticized by calling it "a doctrine worthy only of swine." Explain the meaning of this criticism. https://academic.tips/question/in-chapter-1-on-page-12-of-the-ethical-life-mill-says-that-utilitarianism-has-often-been-criticized-by-calling-it-a-doctrine-worthy-only-of-swine-explain-the-meaning-of-this-cr/
References
Academic.Tips. 2023. "In chapter 1 on page 12 of “The Ethical Life,” Mill says that utilitarianism has often been criticized by calling it "a doctrine worthy only of swine." Explain the meaning of this criticism." February 12, 2023. https://academic.tips/question/in-chapter-1-on-page-12-of-the-ethical-life-mill-says-that-utilitarianism-has-often-been-criticized-by-calling-it-a-doctrine-worthy-only-of-swine-explain-the-meaning-of-this-cr/.
1. Academic.Tips. "In chapter 1 on page 12 of “The Ethical Life,” Mill says that utilitarianism has often been criticized by calling it "a doctrine worthy only of swine." Explain the meaning of this criticism." February 12, 2023. https://academic.tips/question/in-chapter-1-on-page-12-of-the-ethical-life-mill-says-that-utilitarianism-has-often-been-criticized-by-calling-it-a-doctrine-worthy-only-of-swine-explain-the-meaning-of-this-cr/.
Bibliography
Academic.Tips. "In chapter 1 on page 12 of “The Ethical Life,” Mill says that utilitarianism has often been criticized by calling it "a doctrine worthy only of swine." Explain the meaning of this criticism." February 12, 2023. https://academic.tips/question/in-chapter-1-on-page-12-of-the-ethical-life-mill-says-that-utilitarianism-has-often-been-criticized-by-calling-it-a-doctrine-worthy-only-of-swine-explain-the-meaning-of-this-cr/.
Work Cited
"In chapter 1 on page 12 of “The Ethical Life,” Mill says that utilitarianism has often been criticized by calling it "a doctrine worthy only of swine." Explain the meaning of this criticism." Academic.Tips, 12 Feb. 2023, academic.tips/question/in-chapter-1-on-page-12-of-the-ethical-life-mill-says-that-utilitarianism-has-often-been-criticized-by-calling-it-a-doctrine-worthy-only-of-swine-explain-the-meaning-of-this-cr/.
Copy