Billy, a resident of Dallas, Texas, was having trouble paying his bills. Along with his best friend Edward, he decided that they would rob a bank in neighboring Wichita Falls to raise some funds. Billy and Edward ended up taking a hostage and driving to nearby Randlett, Oklahoma, where they took refuge in Edward’s grandmother’s home. Both Billy and Edward eventually were apprehended in Randlett, and the hostage was released. Which court would possess jurisdiction over this case—state or federal?

A

Based on the aforementioned details, Billy and Edward’s case would be heard in the federal court. As noted in the “1349. Bank robbery,” bank robbery is a felony, falling under the category of federal crimes. However, Hoffman and Stuntz clarify that many US states, including Texas, define bank robbery as a state crime. The right to arbitrary in case of such controversy belongs to the state court, provided the amount of damage is less than 75 thousand dollars. Notwithstanding this clarification, the federal court would still possess jurisdiction over Billy and Edward’s case since the bank robbery was accompanied by a hostage. As stated in the Hostage Taking Act, hostage that occurred within the territory of the United States qualifies as a federal offense, falling under the jurisdiction of the federal court. Regardless of the amount of damage, the felony would be judged according to the federal statute.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in law. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2021) 'Billy, a resident of Dallas, Texas, was having trouble paying his bills. Along with his best friend Edward, he decided that they would rob a bank in neighboring Wichita Falls to raise some funds. Billy and Edward ended up taking a hostage and driving to nearby Randlett, Oklahoma, where they took refuge in Edward’s grandmother’s home. Both Billy and Edward eventually were apprehended in Randlett, and the hostage was released. Which court would possess jurisdiction over this case—state or federal'. 25 June.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2021, June 25). Billy, a resident of Dallas, Texas, was having trouble paying his bills. Along with his best friend Edward, he decided that they would rob a bank in neighboring Wichita Falls to raise some funds. Billy and Edward ended up taking a hostage and driving to nearby Randlett, Oklahoma, where they took refuge in Edward’s grandmother’s home. Both Billy and Edward eventually were apprehended in Randlett, and the hostage was released. Which court would possess jurisdiction over this case—state or federal? Retrieved from https://academic.tips/question/billy-a-resident-of-dallas-texas-was-having-trouble-paying-his-bills-along-with-his-best-friend-edward-he-decided-that-they-would-rob-a-bank-in-neighboring-wichita-falls-to-raise-some-funds-bill/

References

Academic.Tips. 2021. "Billy, a resident of Dallas, Texas, was having trouble paying his bills. Along with his best friend Edward, he decided that they would rob a bank in neighboring Wichita Falls to raise some funds. Billy and Edward ended up taking a hostage and driving to nearby Randlett, Oklahoma, where they took refuge in Edward’s grandmother’s home. Both Billy and Edward eventually were apprehended in Randlett, and the hostage was released. Which court would possess jurisdiction over this case—state or federal?" June 25, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/billy-a-resident-of-dallas-texas-was-having-trouble-paying-his-bills-along-with-his-best-friend-edward-he-decided-that-they-would-rob-a-bank-in-neighboring-wichita-falls-to-raise-some-funds-bill/.

1. Academic.Tips. "Billy, a resident of Dallas, Texas, was having trouble paying his bills. Along with his best friend Edward, he decided that they would rob a bank in neighboring Wichita Falls to raise some funds. Billy and Edward ended up taking a hostage and driving to nearby Randlett, Oklahoma, where they took refuge in Edward’s grandmother’s home. Both Billy and Edward eventually were apprehended in Randlett, and the hostage was released. Which court would possess jurisdiction over this case—state or federal?" June 25, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/billy-a-resident-of-dallas-texas-was-having-trouble-paying-his-bills-along-with-his-best-friend-edward-he-decided-that-they-would-rob-a-bank-in-neighboring-wichita-falls-to-raise-some-funds-bill/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "Billy, a resident of Dallas, Texas, was having trouble paying his bills. Along with his best friend Edward, he decided that they would rob a bank in neighboring Wichita Falls to raise some funds. Billy and Edward ended up taking a hostage and driving to nearby Randlett, Oklahoma, where they took refuge in Edward’s grandmother’s home. Both Billy and Edward eventually were apprehended in Randlett, and the hostage was released. Which court would possess jurisdiction over this case—state or federal?" June 25, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/billy-a-resident-of-dallas-texas-was-having-trouble-paying-his-bills-along-with-his-best-friend-edward-he-decided-that-they-would-rob-a-bank-in-neighboring-wichita-falls-to-raise-some-funds-bill/.

Work Cited

"Billy, a resident of Dallas, Texas, was having trouble paying his bills. Along with his best friend Edward, he decided that they would rob a bank in neighboring Wichita Falls to raise some funds. Billy and Edward ended up taking a hostage and driving to nearby Randlett, Oklahoma, where they took refuge in Edward’s grandmother’s home. Both Billy and Edward eventually were apprehended in Randlett, and the hostage was released. Which court would possess jurisdiction over this case—state or federal?" Academic.Tips, 25 June 2021, academic.tips/question/billy-a-resident-of-dallas-texas-was-having-trouble-paying-his-bills-along-with-his-best-friend-edward-he-decided-that-they-would-rob-a-bank-in-neighboring-wichita-falls-to-raise-some-funds-bill/.

Copy