The facility you work for wants to pilot a program to allow parents to choose the sex of their child and has scheduled an open forum meeting for hospital staff and physicians. The physicians are in favor of this action and the staff is opposed. You were selected to speak for the staff and the topic is Genetic Modification of Human Beings: Is it Acceptable? How would you prepare for the forum and what information would you want to have? How would you utilize your critical thinking skills when asked questions?

The preparation for the forum about the issue of genome editing requires one to consider the topic from different angles. First of all, it is vital to address the health-related consequences of the sex selection procedure. According to Kang et al., CRISPR (clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats) editing procedure, while being widely discussed, is not entirely devoid of risks and drawbacks. Thus, a lack of preparation and research may subject parents and their future children to many dangers. Here, the information needs to contain cases of adverse outcomes as well as recommendations of specialists who urge to prevent the use of genome editing before it is studied sufficiently. Kang et al., for example, suggest postponing the introduction of genome editing before the global community conducts exhaustive research.

Moreover, ethical considerations should also be brought up during the meeting. Sex selection does not have the same implications and necessity as genome editing for genetic diseases. In the case of severe life-threatening conditions, the ethics of genome modification can make the procedure understandable and necessary for the health of the future child. In contrast, the selection of one’s sex cannot be agreed upon using the same arguments since this procedure is not performed to save an individual from health-related problems. As Shahvisi notes, most parents who want to choose their child’s sex provide the reason for “family balancing.” This argument implies that, in families, the distribution of sexes is incorrect in some way. Here, the information about potential discrimination sources will build the foundation for the ethical argument. When answering questions, one can use this data to oppose positive interpretations of sex selection to pinpoint the risks and uncertainties of granting access to the procedure.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in biology. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2021) 'The facility you work for wants to pilot a program to allow parents to choose the sex of their child and has scheduled an open forum meeting for hospital staff and physicians. The physicians are in favor of this action and the staff is opposed. You were selected to speak for the staff and the topic is Genetic Modification of Human Beings: Is it Acceptable? How would you prepare for the forum and what information would you want to have? How would you utilize your critical thinking skills when asked questions'. 25 June.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2021, June 25). The facility you work for wants to pilot a program to allow parents to choose the sex of their child and has scheduled an open forum meeting for hospital staff and physicians. The physicians are in favor of this action and the staff is opposed. You were selected to speak for the staff and the topic is Genetic Modification of Human Beings: Is it Acceptable? How would you prepare for the forum and what information would you want to have? How would you utilize your critical thinking skills when asked questions? https://academic.tips/question/the-facility-you-work-for-wants-to-pilot-a-program-to-allow-parents-to-choose-the-sex-of-their-child-and-has-scheduled-an-open-forum-meeting-for-hospital-staff-and-physicians-the-physicians-are-in-fa/

References

Academic.Tips. 2021. "The facility you work for wants to pilot a program to allow parents to choose the sex of their child and has scheduled an open forum meeting for hospital staff and physicians. The physicians are in favor of this action and the staff is opposed. You were selected to speak for the staff and the topic is Genetic Modification of Human Beings: Is it Acceptable? How would you prepare for the forum and what information would you want to have? How would you utilize your critical thinking skills when asked questions?" June 25, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/the-facility-you-work-for-wants-to-pilot-a-program-to-allow-parents-to-choose-the-sex-of-their-child-and-has-scheduled-an-open-forum-meeting-for-hospital-staff-and-physicians-the-physicians-are-in-fa/.

1. Academic.Tips. "The facility you work for wants to pilot a program to allow parents to choose the sex of their child and has scheduled an open forum meeting for hospital staff and physicians. The physicians are in favor of this action and the staff is opposed. You were selected to speak for the staff and the topic is Genetic Modification of Human Beings: Is it Acceptable? How would you prepare for the forum and what information would you want to have? How would you utilize your critical thinking skills when asked questions?" June 25, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/the-facility-you-work-for-wants-to-pilot-a-program-to-allow-parents-to-choose-the-sex-of-their-child-and-has-scheduled-an-open-forum-meeting-for-hospital-staff-and-physicians-the-physicians-are-in-fa/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "The facility you work for wants to pilot a program to allow parents to choose the sex of their child and has scheduled an open forum meeting for hospital staff and physicians. The physicians are in favor of this action and the staff is opposed. You were selected to speak for the staff and the topic is Genetic Modification of Human Beings: Is it Acceptable? How would you prepare for the forum and what information would you want to have? How would you utilize your critical thinking skills when asked questions?" June 25, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/the-facility-you-work-for-wants-to-pilot-a-program-to-allow-parents-to-choose-the-sex-of-their-child-and-has-scheduled-an-open-forum-meeting-for-hospital-staff-and-physicians-the-physicians-are-in-fa/.

Work Cited

"The facility you work for wants to pilot a program to allow parents to choose the sex of their child and has scheduled an open forum meeting for hospital staff and physicians. The physicians are in favor of this action and the staff is opposed. You were selected to speak for the staff and the topic is Genetic Modification of Human Beings: Is it Acceptable? How would you prepare for the forum and what information would you want to have? How would you utilize your critical thinking skills when asked questions?" Academic.Tips, 25 June 2021, academic.tips/question/the-facility-you-work-for-wants-to-pilot-a-program-to-allow-parents-to-choose-the-sex-of-their-child-and-has-scheduled-an-open-forum-meeting-for-hospital-staff-and-physicians-the-physicians-are-in-fa/.

Copy