Why is the Necessary and Proper Clause a source of ongoing debate? A) Congress cannot agree on how broad its implied powers should be. B) The wording of the clause is often undergoing revision. C) The clause deals with specified powers that are ambiguous and misinterpreted. D) The clause establishes reserved rights, which vary from state to state.

A

C. The clause deals with specified powers that are ambiguous and misinterpreted.

Explanation:

The Necessary and Proper Clause, located in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution, that gives the Congress to power to make any laws that are “necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof.” As it is contained within the Constitution, the text cannot be changed easily, which forces Congress to settle on an interpretation.

Necessary and proper doesn't mean whatever we want.
An Argument Against Broad Interpretations of the Necessary and Proper Clause (Source: http://tenthamendment.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com)

As can be seen in the text, the powers described in the clause are not clearly defined. Debates over the interpretation have been ongoing since the time of Thomas Jefferson and are still not over.

Different applications of the clause would change the implied powers of the Congress and individual states, but the debates concern the interpretation of the text. The document is supposed to be the foundation of the United States and resist interest-based arguments.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in linguistics. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2020) 'Why is the Necessary and Proper Clause a source of ongoing debate? A) Congress cannot agree on how broad its implied powers should be. B) The wording of the clause is often undergoing revision. C) The clause deals with specified powers that are ambiguous and misinterpreted. D) The clause establishes reserved rights, which vary from state to state'. 27 March.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2020, March 27). Why is the Necessary and Proper Clause a source of ongoing debate? A) Congress cannot agree on how broad its implied powers should be. B) The wording of the clause is often undergoing revision. C) The clause deals with specified powers that are ambiguous and misinterpreted. D) The clause establishes reserved rights, which vary from state to state. Retrieved from https://academic.tips/question/why-is-the-necessary-and-proper-clause-a-source-of-ongoing-debate/

References

Academic.Tips. 2020. "Why is the Necessary and Proper Clause a source of ongoing debate? A) Congress cannot agree on how broad its implied powers should be. B) The wording of the clause is often undergoing revision. C) The clause deals with specified powers that are ambiguous and misinterpreted. D) The clause establishes reserved rights, which vary from state to state." March 27, 2020. https://academic.tips/question/why-is-the-necessary-and-proper-clause-a-source-of-ongoing-debate/.

1. Academic.Tips. "Why is the Necessary and Proper Clause a source of ongoing debate? A) Congress cannot agree on how broad its implied powers should be. B) The wording of the clause is often undergoing revision. C) The clause deals with specified powers that are ambiguous and misinterpreted. D) The clause establishes reserved rights, which vary from state to state." March 27, 2020. https://academic.tips/question/why-is-the-necessary-and-proper-clause-a-source-of-ongoing-debate/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "Why is the Necessary and Proper Clause a source of ongoing debate? A) Congress cannot agree on how broad its implied powers should be. B) The wording of the clause is often undergoing revision. C) The clause deals with specified powers that are ambiguous and misinterpreted. D) The clause establishes reserved rights, which vary from state to state." March 27, 2020. https://academic.tips/question/why-is-the-necessary-and-proper-clause-a-source-of-ongoing-debate/.

Work Cited

"Why is the Necessary and Proper Clause a source of ongoing debate? A) Congress cannot agree on how broad its implied powers should be. B) The wording of the clause is often undergoing revision. C) The clause deals with specified powers that are ambiguous and misinterpreted. D) The clause establishes reserved rights, which vary from state to state." Academic.Tips, 27 Mar. 2020, academic.tips/question/why-is-the-necessary-and-proper-clause-a-source-of-ongoing-debate/.

Copy