Categories
Home/Social Studies/Why does Berkeley deny the existence of material objects? Explain his view of subjective idealism. Do you accept or reject his theory? Why or why not? Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley’s idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley’s view is false? Explain.

Why does Berkeley deny the existence of material objects? Explain his view of subjective idealism. Do you accept or reject his theory? Why or why not? Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley’s idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley’s view is false? Explain.

Berkeley believed that the human mind is responsible for the existence of materials, and without the mind’s perception, any material is non-existent. He supports his point by claiming that people cannot prove that any material is not a simple creation of their minds. I strongly oppose his ideas because materials that are tangible and external to our bodies are genuine and do exist beyond our thinking process. Consider a scenario with a person who cannot see and hear. As the person walks down the road, they cannot perceive with their eyes or ears. They have no idea about the physical objects that surround them, but this fact does not mean that these objects do not exist. If the person were to bump into one of the objects unintentionally, they would feel it because the material exists.

A popular method of refuting Berkeley’s idea of Subjective Idealism is simply doing something with a physical matter. Samuel Johnson, for instance, kicked a rock to claim that Berkeley is wrong. However, such actions cannot serve as a strong argument against Berkeley’s ideas because both persons perceive the same object, and it can be argued that this object is simply a result of both of the person’s thinking processes. To successfully refute the idea of subjective idealism, a person that is not capable of perceiving through their senses should interact with the object and show that this physical matter is real, although the person had not known about it.

Rate the answer:
Views: 189
Further research on topic
Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in social studies. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2022) 'Why does Berkeley deny the existence of material objects? Explain his view of subjective idealism. Do you accept or reject his theory? Why or why not? Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain'. 14 February.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2022, February 14). Why does Berkeley deny the existence of material objects? Explain his view of subjective idealism. Do you accept or reject his theory? Why or why not? Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain. https://academic.tips/question/why-does-berkeley-deny-the-existence-of-material-objects-explain-his-view-of-subjective-idealism-do-you-accept-or-reject-his-theory-why-or-why-not-suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute/

References

Academic.Tips. 2022. "Why does Berkeley deny the existence of material objects? Explain his view of subjective idealism. Do you accept or reject his theory? Why or why not? Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain." February 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/why-does-berkeley-deny-the-existence-of-material-objects-explain-his-view-of-subjective-idealism-do-you-accept-or-reject-his-theory-why-or-why-not-suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute/.

1. Academic.Tips. "Why does Berkeley deny the existence of material objects? Explain his view of subjective idealism. Do you accept or reject his theory? Why or why not? Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain." February 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/why-does-berkeley-deny-the-existence-of-material-objects-explain-his-view-of-subjective-idealism-do-you-accept-or-reject-his-theory-why-or-why-not-suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "Why does Berkeley deny the existence of material objects? Explain his view of subjective idealism. Do you accept or reject his theory? Why or why not? Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain." February 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/why-does-berkeley-deny-the-existence-of-material-objects-explain-his-view-of-subjective-idealism-do-you-accept-or-reject-his-theory-why-or-why-not-suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute/.

Work Cited

"Why does Berkeley deny the existence of material objects? Explain his view of subjective idealism. Do you accept or reject his theory? Why or why not? Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain." Academic.Tips, 14 Feb. 2022, academic.tips/question/why-does-berkeley-deny-the-existence-of-material-objects-explain-his-view-of-subjective-idealism-do-you-accept-or-reject-his-theory-why-or-why-not-suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute/.

Copy
Is there a rational theoretical basis to the modern movement against inter-ethnic marriage, especially in regard to Africana and European cultures? How does the American capitalist interest support or negate the idea of inter-ethnic marriage?
Indira Gandhi, the late Indian prime minister, said in 1982 an address to the World Health Assembly, “The idea of a better-ordered world is one in which medical discoveries will be free of patents and there will be no profiteering from life and death.” Patents are property rights over intellectual discoveries. What do you think of Gandhi’s statement?
Check the price of your paper