Categories
Home/Law/While on routine patrol you’re dispatched to an apartment building where there’s been a report of a male disturbing the peace. As you and your partner arrive on the scene, the apartment manager informs you that the tenant on the second floor is threatening other tenants. Upon reaching the suspect you begin shouting commands for the subject to place his hands where they can be seen. The subject isn’t complying with the commands and is acting in a way that you’re trained to understand may be linked to mental health illness. What do you do? Explain your answer.

While on routine patrol you’re dispatched to an apartment building where there’s been a report of a male disturbing the peace. As you and your partner arrive on the scene, the apartment manager informs you that the tenant on the second floor is threatening other tenants. Upon reaching the suspect you begin shouting commands for the subject to place his hands where they can be seen. The subject isn’t complying with the commands and is acting in a way that you’re trained to understand may be linked to mental health illness. What do you do? Explain your answer.

The law allows an officer to use force to maintain civility. An ethical dilemma arises between the choice of use of coercion or crisis intervention strategies. There are situations that call for the use of compulsion for mentally instability cases. If an officer is plausible to be attacked by the suspect or the defendant is likely to harm himself, then crisis intervention strategies are ruled out.

As far as this case is concerned, I will arrest the suspect and, if it demands, use force. The generalization principle needs to be applied here because the decision I make must relate to anyone in a similar situation as the man disturbing the peace. Whether the suspect is mentally incapacitated or not, there is a misdeed. Moreover, it is the duty of a police officer to maintain order. Therefore, using force can be supported in this case because either the suspect can injure himself or even me, who has gone to arrest him. Clearly, the application of force is meant to reduce any possible harm to anyone.

Lastly, the method adopted in dealing with mental cases by a police officer depends on any imminent danger. There are situations where suspects are non-violent but cooperative with the police officers. Certainly, such incidents require crisis intervention strategies because the use of impetus is of no service. Therefore, self-preservation should guide the use of force or crisis intervention strategies in police decisions before taking any of the approaches.

Rate the answer:
Views: 8
Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in law. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2022) 'While on routine patrol you’re dispatched to an apartment building where there’s been a report of a male disturbing the peace. As you and your partner arrive on the scene, the apartment manager informs you that the tenant on the second floor is threatening other tenants. Upon reaching the suspect you begin shouting commands for the subject to place his hands where they can be seen. The subject isn’t complying with the commands and is acting in a way that you’re trained to understand may be linked to mental health illness. What do you do? Explain your answer'. 14 June.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2022, June 14). While on routine patrol you’re dispatched to an apartment building where there’s been a report of a male disturbing the peace. As you and your partner arrive on the scene, the apartment manager informs you that the tenant on the second floor is threatening other tenants. Upon reaching the suspect you begin shouting commands for the subject to place his hands where they can be seen. The subject isn’t complying with the commands and is acting in a way that you’re trained to understand may be linked to mental health illness. What do you do? Explain your answer. https://academic.tips/question/while-on-routine-patrol-youre-dispatched-to-an-apartment-building-where-theres-been-a-report-of-a-male-disturbing-the-peace-as-you-and-your-partner-arrive-on-the-scene-the-apartmen/

References

Academic.Tips. 2022. "While on routine patrol you’re dispatched to an apartment building where there’s been a report of a male disturbing the peace. As you and your partner arrive on the scene, the apartment manager informs you that the tenant on the second floor is threatening other tenants. Upon reaching the suspect you begin shouting commands for the subject to place his hands where they can be seen. The subject isn’t complying with the commands and is acting in a way that you’re trained to understand may be linked to mental health illness. What do you do? Explain your answer." June 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/while-on-routine-patrol-youre-dispatched-to-an-apartment-building-where-theres-been-a-report-of-a-male-disturbing-the-peace-as-you-and-your-partner-arrive-on-the-scene-the-apartmen/.

1. Academic.Tips. "While on routine patrol you’re dispatched to an apartment building where there’s been a report of a male disturbing the peace. As you and your partner arrive on the scene, the apartment manager informs you that the tenant on the second floor is threatening other tenants. Upon reaching the suspect you begin shouting commands for the subject to place his hands where they can be seen. The subject isn’t complying with the commands and is acting in a way that you’re trained to understand may be linked to mental health illness. What do you do? Explain your answer." June 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/while-on-routine-patrol-youre-dispatched-to-an-apartment-building-where-theres-been-a-report-of-a-male-disturbing-the-peace-as-you-and-your-partner-arrive-on-the-scene-the-apartmen/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "While on routine patrol you’re dispatched to an apartment building where there’s been a report of a male disturbing the peace. As you and your partner arrive on the scene, the apartment manager informs you that the tenant on the second floor is threatening other tenants. Upon reaching the suspect you begin shouting commands for the subject to place his hands where they can be seen. The subject isn’t complying with the commands and is acting in a way that you’re trained to understand may be linked to mental health illness. What do you do? Explain your answer." June 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/while-on-routine-patrol-youre-dispatched-to-an-apartment-building-where-theres-been-a-report-of-a-male-disturbing-the-peace-as-you-and-your-partner-arrive-on-the-scene-the-apartmen/.

Work Cited

"While on routine patrol you’re dispatched to an apartment building where there’s been a report of a male disturbing the peace. As you and your partner arrive on the scene, the apartment manager informs you that the tenant on the second floor is threatening other tenants. Upon reaching the suspect you begin shouting commands for the subject to place his hands where they can be seen. The subject isn’t complying with the commands and is acting in a way that you’re trained to understand may be linked to mental health illness. What do you do? Explain your answer." Academic.Tips, 14 June 2022, academic.tips/question/while-on-routine-patrol-youre-dispatched-to-an-apartment-building-where-theres-been-a-report-of-a-male-disturbing-the-peace-as-you-and-your-partner-arrive-on-the-scene-the-apartmen/.

Copy
We know an officer cannot stop or arrest a person based on a "hunch". However, in Whren v. U.S., the U.S. Supreme Court upheld a '"pretext arrest". Does the Whren decision encourage law enforcement to "circumvent" the legal system? Why or why not?
In the course of your investigation of the gun advocacy group, you have to go to your local county prison to question one of the group members being held there pending trial. This particular individual has been a problem inmate and is being held in solitary confinement. He’s to have no contact with other members of the group. You meet with him alone in a private interrogation room. He knows that you generally support the group, and he does his best to answer your questions, although his answers aren’t as complete as you would like. At the end of the questioning – just before he rises to leave the room – he slips you a note in a sealed envelope and asks that you give it to someone who is involved in the gun advocacy group. He says it’s very important and implores you to just hand it to the person or drop it in the mail. He then leaves the interrogation room. What do you do? Explain your answer.
Check the price of your paper