What point is Taylor attempting to make when he uses the example of the stones scattered on the hillside resembling the letters: The British Railyway Welcomes You to Wales? What is the second example he uses to illustrate this same point? How are these two examples connected to Taylor’s discussion of human sense organs, and the human brain and nervous system? Explain.

Taylor’s utility of the example of the stones on the British Railways is an implication that no one can prove that these stones were purposefully arranged by anyone or they just happened to be on that order accidentally. He says that it is possible that the stones rolled from the hill over centuries and arranged themselves in that kind of interesting arrangement. It could also be possible that the British Railways company made the arrangement purposefully for its customers arriving in Wales.

The other example that Taylor used is the one where a stone was found to have been excavated from the ground with some marks on it, which resembled a purposeful activity of decorating it. Later, geologists started to explain the shapes and marks on the stone and said that they resembled characters of ancient alphabets. It now became hard to prove who really inscribed the marks on the stone. It could have been the effects of volcanic activities and earthquakes, or even glaciation. Scholars found the stone to have marks that read a war leader in the Athenian war. Though they resembled an intelligent message, it was hard to prove. It could also have been a king who might have died and buried there with the stone as part of his artifacts.

The two examples of stones that were found to have no proof and their implications were closely related to the human sensory organs, especially the eye. The eye functions like a camera, but it can not take any photos. It is not even proven to relate to the camera since the camera can not see. Also, the human sensory organ is complex and seemingly purposeful, but we cannot in the real sense justify their arrangements in the body, and yet they are useful in our bodies. The same is with the stones of the British Railways that could have probably fallen from the nearby hill forming such an arrangement.

All these incidences remained a source of contradiction since no one could really justify their causes explicitly. It would be irrational for anyone to say that the marks found on the stone had a natural and non purposeful origin and also that they reveal some truth with respect to something other than themselves. However, one can not rationally believe both of the things. It would thus be irrational for anyone to say that his sensory and cognitive facilities had a natural and a non-purposeful origin and also that they revealed some truth with respect to something else other than themselves, one that is not inferred from them. If then, their origins can be accounted for in terms of chance variations or natural selection since they did not come to existence by themselves. They are not in themselves reliable truths on whatever brought them to their structures and arrangement. At the same time, we can not say they have no truth in their existence in themselves.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in social studies. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2022) 'What point is Taylor attempting to make when he uses the example of the stones scattered on the hillside resembling the letters: The British Railyway Welcomes You to Wales? What is the second example he uses to illustrate this same point? How are these two examples connected to Taylor's discussion of human sense organs, and the human brain and nervous system? Explain'. 21 June.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2022, June 21). What point is Taylor attempting to make when he uses the example of the stones scattered on the hillside resembling the letters: The British Railyway Welcomes You to Wales? What is the second example he uses to illustrate this same point? How are these two examples connected to Taylor's discussion of human sense organs, and the human brain and nervous system? Explain. Retrieved from https://academic.tips/question/what-point-is-taylor-attempting-to-make-when-he-uses-the-example-of-the-stones-scattered-on-the-hillside-resembling-the-letters-the-british-railyway-welcomes-you-to-wales-what-is-the-second-example/

References

Academic.Tips. 2022. "What point is Taylor attempting to make when he uses the example of the stones scattered on the hillside resembling the letters: The British Railyway Welcomes You to Wales? What is the second example he uses to illustrate this same point? How are these two examples connected to Taylor's discussion of human sense organs, and the human brain and nervous system? Explain." June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/what-point-is-taylor-attempting-to-make-when-he-uses-the-example-of-the-stones-scattered-on-the-hillside-resembling-the-letters-the-british-railyway-welcomes-you-to-wales-what-is-the-second-example/.

1. Academic.Tips. "What point is Taylor attempting to make when he uses the example of the stones scattered on the hillside resembling the letters: The British Railyway Welcomes You to Wales? What is the second example he uses to illustrate this same point? How are these two examples connected to Taylor's discussion of human sense organs, and the human brain and nervous system? Explain." June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/what-point-is-taylor-attempting-to-make-when-he-uses-the-example-of-the-stones-scattered-on-the-hillside-resembling-the-letters-the-british-railyway-welcomes-you-to-wales-what-is-the-second-example/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "What point is Taylor attempting to make when he uses the example of the stones scattered on the hillside resembling the letters: The British Railyway Welcomes You to Wales? What is the second example he uses to illustrate this same point? How are these two examples connected to Taylor's discussion of human sense organs, and the human brain and nervous system? Explain." June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/what-point-is-taylor-attempting-to-make-when-he-uses-the-example-of-the-stones-scattered-on-the-hillside-resembling-the-letters-the-british-railyway-welcomes-you-to-wales-what-is-the-second-example/.

Work Cited

"What point is Taylor attempting to make when he uses the example of the stones scattered on the hillside resembling the letters: The British Railyway Welcomes You to Wales? What is the second example he uses to illustrate this same point? How are these two examples connected to Taylor's discussion of human sense organs, and the human brain and nervous system? Explain." Academic.Tips, 21 June 2022, academic.tips/question/what-point-is-taylor-attempting-to-make-when-he-uses-the-example-of-the-stones-scattered-on-the-hillside-resembling-the-letters-the-british-railyway-welcomes-you-to-wales-what-is-the-second-example/.

Copy