Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley’s idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley’s view is false? Explain.

Need a paper written? Our academic experts can create an original essay on any subject for ~~$13.00~~ $11/page Learn More

Kicking a rock does not show that Berkeley’s view of knowledge is false. I think Berkeley was making a case against Locke’s claim that all that we know are mental pictures of certain objects as opposed to the objects themselves. He says, “the supposition that things are distinct from ideas takes away all real truth and consequently brings in a universal scepticism.” In this case, kicking a rock is absurd because Berkeley does not refute the existence of the same. The contentious issue is whether the rock exists as an object or an idea because according to Berkeley, the two are inseparable.

Rate the answer:

Further research on topic

Berkeley and Locke: If a Tree Falls in a Forest

Answer by Academic.tip's expert

An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2022) 'Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain'. 14 February.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2022, February 14). Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain. https://academic.tips/question/suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute-berkeleys-idealism-by-simply-kicking-a-rock-or-eating-an-apple-does-this-demonstration-show-that-berkeleys-view-is-false-explain/

References

Academic.Tips. 2022. "Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain." February 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute-berkeleys-idealism-by-simply-kicking-a-rock-or-eating-an-apple-does-this-demonstration-show-that-berkeleys-view-is-false-explain/.

1. Academic.Tips. "Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain." February 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute-berkeleys-idealism-by-simply-kicking-a-rock-or-eating-an-apple-does-this-demonstration-show-that-berkeleys-view-is-false-explain/.

Bibliography

Academic.Tips. "Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain." February 14, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute-berkeleys-idealism-by-simply-kicking-a-rock-or-eating-an-apple-does-this-demonstration-show-that-berkeleys-view-is-false-explain/.

Work Cited

"Suppose someone claims that he can easily refute Berkeley's idealism by simply kicking a rock or eating an apple. Does this demonstration show that Berkeley's view is false? Explain." Academic.Tips, 14 Feb. 2022, academic.tips/question/suppose-someone-claims-that-he-can-easily-refute-berkeleys-idealism-by-simply-kicking-a-rock-or-eating-an-apple-does-this-demonstration-show-that-berkeleys-view-is-false-explain/.

Copy