Other people have suggested that the purpose of evil is to discipline and improve us – not to punish us. They suggest that the world is really a moral training ground for building up our characters. How does Hospers respond to this?

Hospers claims that, however, the pain is something necessary to feel relief, it does not mean that physician should arbitrarily cause pain in this patient. If applied to God, it means that the notions of good and just run in great contradiction to conscious initiating of the evil. If God created such conditions, it would mean that his moral position is wrong and ruining. In my view, this vision is similar to some kind of spiritual masochism that should be avoided by any means.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in philosophy. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2022) 'Other people have suggested that the purpose of evil is to discipline and improve us – not to punish us. They suggest that the world is really a moral training ground for building up our characters. How does Hospers respond to this'. 21 June.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2022, June 21). Other people have suggested that the purpose of evil is to discipline and improve us – not to punish us. They suggest that the world is really a moral training ground for building up our characters. How does Hospers respond to this? Retrieved from https://academic.tips/question/other-people-have-suggested-that-the-purpose-of-evil-is-to-discipline-and-improve-us-not-to-punish-us-they-suggest-that-the-world-is-really-a-moral-training-ground-for-building-up-our-chara/

References

Academic.Tips. 2022. "Other people have suggested that the purpose of evil is to discipline and improve us – not to punish us. They suggest that the world is really a moral training ground for building up our characters. How does Hospers respond to this?" June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/other-people-have-suggested-that-the-purpose-of-evil-is-to-discipline-and-improve-us-not-to-punish-us-they-suggest-that-the-world-is-really-a-moral-training-ground-for-building-up-our-chara/.

1. Academic.Tips. "Other people have suggested that the purpose of evil is to discipline and improve us – not to punish us. They suggest that the world is really a moral training ground for building up our characters. How does Hospers respond to this?" June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/other-people-have-suggested-that-the-purpose-of-evil-is-to-discipline-and-improve-us-not-to-punish-us-they-suggest-that-the-world-is-really-a-moral-training-ground-for-building-up-our-chara/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "Other people have suggested that the purpose of evil is to discipline and improve us – not to punish us. They suggest that the world is really a moral training ground for building up our characters. How does Hospers respond to this?" June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/other-people-have-suggested-that-the-purpose-of-evil-is-to-discipline-and-improve-us-not-to-punish-us-they-suggest-that-the-world-is-really-a-moral-training-ground-for-building-up-our-chara/.

Work Cited

"Other people have suggested that the purpose of evil is to discipline and improve us – not to punish us. They suggest that the world is really a moral training ground for building up our characters. How does Hospers respond to this?" Academic.Tips, 21 June 2022, academic.tips/question/other-people-have-suggested-that-the-purpose-of-evil-is-to-discipline-and-improve-us-not-to-punish-us-they-suggest-that-the-world-is-really-a-moral-training-ground-for-building-up-our-chara/.

Copy