It has been suggested that when we say a person “ought to do X” or “ought not to do Y” we mean only that this person’s behavior is inconvenient to us. Why does Lewis reject this idea?

The explanation by Lewis that a person ought to do X or Y to be inconvenient was because he rejected the fact of generalization based on the law of human nature and the moral law. He says that such a judgment does not give a timely justifiable answer that needs to be followed. This is so because of the law of behavior which proves us opposite in the way we think.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in social studies. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2022) 'It has been suggested that when we say a person "ought to do X" or "ought not to do Y" we mean only that this person's behavior is inconvenient to us. Why does Lewis reject this idea'. 21 June.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2022, June 21). It has been suggested that when we say a person "ought to do X" or "ought not to do Y" we mean only that this person's behavior is inconvenient to us. Why does Lewis reject this idea? Retrieved from https://academic.tips/question/it-has-been-suggested-that-when-we-say-a-person-ought-to-do-x-or-ought-not-to-do-y-we-mean-only-that-this-persons-behavior-is-inconvenient-to-us-why-does-lewis-reject-this-idea/

References

Academic.Tips. 2022. "It has been suggested that when we say a person "ought to do X" or "ought not to do Y" we mean only that this person's behavior is inconvenient to us. Why does Lewis reject this idea?" June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/it-has-been-suggested-that-when-we-say-a-person-ought-to-do-x-or-ought-not-to-do-y-we-mean-only-that-this-persons-behavior-is-inconvenient-to-us-why-does-lewis-reject-this-idea/.

1. Academic.Tips. "It has been suggested that when we say a person "ought to do X" or "ought not to do Y" we mean only that this person's behavior is inconvenient to us. Why does Lewis reject this idea?" June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/it-has-been-suggested-that-when-we-say-a-person-ought-to-do-x-or-ought-not-to-do-y-we-mean-only-that-this-persons-behavior-is-inconvenient-to-us-why-does-lewis-reject-this-idea/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "It has been suggested that when we say a person "ought to do X" or "ought not to do Y" we mean only that this person's behavior is inconvenient to us. Why does Lewis reject this idea?" June 21, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/it-has-been-suggested-that-when-we-say-a-person-ought-to-do-x-or-ought-not-to-do-y-we-mean-only-that-this-persons-behavior-is-inconvenient-to-us-why-does-lewis-reject-this-idea/.

Work Cited

"It has been suggested that when we say a person "ought to do X" or "ought not to do Y" we mean only that this person's behavior is inconvenient to us. Why does Lewis reject this idea?" Academic.Tips, 21 June 2022, academic.tips/question/it-has-been-suggested-that-when-we-say-a-person-ought-to-do-x-or-ought-not-to-do-y-we-mean-only-that-this-persons-behavior-is-inconvenient-to-us-why-does-lewis-reject-this-idea/.

Copy