For the following claims, write one paragraph identifying the logical flaw: The decrease in smoking can be attributed to increased restrictions on smoking in public.

A

The case under analysis represents a logical flaw defined by the disruption in the cause-and-effect relationship. Known as the post hoc fallacy, or the problem of correlation versus causation, the logical flaw is quite evident in the false assumption that two phenomena following each other are intrinsically related. At this point, one should mention that the provided statement is not entirely flawed since it may be true in some circumstances. In cases where the change in legislation has the only possible factor that could have caused alterations in people’s behaviors, the specified instance could be true. However, in the scenario under analysis, the provided details are not enough to infer that the law was the main cause behind the reduction in smoking rates. This could have been informed about the detrimental effects of smoking on health that has altered the public’s attitude toward the subject matter.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2021) 'For the following claims, write one paragraph identifying the logical flaw: The decrease in smoking can be attributed to increased restrictions on smoking in public'. 8 July.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2021, July 8). For the following claims, write one paragraph identifying the logical flaw: The decrease in smoking can be attributed to increased restrictions on smoking in public. Retrieved from https://academic.tips/question/for-the-following-claims-write-one-paragraph-identifying-the-logical-flaw-the-decrease-in-smoking-can-be-attributed-to-increased-restrictions-on-smoking-in-public/

References

Academic.Tips. 2021. "For the following claims, write one paragraph identifying the logical flaw: The decrease in smoking can be attributed to increased restrictions on smoking in public." July 8, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/for-the-following-claims-write-one-paragraph-identifying-the-logical-flaw-the-decrease-in-smoking-can-be-attributed-to-increased-restrictions-on-smoking-in-public/.

1. Academic.Tips. "For the following claims, write one paragraph identifying the logical flaw: The decrease in smoking can be attributed to increased restrictions on smoking in public." July 8, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/for-the-following-claims-write-one-paragraph-identifying-the-logical-flaw-the-decrease-in-smoking-can-be-attributed-to-increased-restrictions-on-smoking-in-public/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "For the following claims, write one paragraph identifying the logical flaw: The decrease in smoking can be attributed to increased restrictions on smoking in public." July 8, 2021. https://academic.tips/question/for-the-following-claims-write-one-paragraph-identifying-the-logical-flaw-the-decrease-in-smoking-can-be-attributed-to-increased-restrictions-on-smoking-in-public/.

Work Cited

"For the following claims, write one paragraph identifying the logical flaw: The decrease in smoking can be attributed to increased restrictions on smoking in public." Academic.Tips, 8 July 2021, academic.tips/question/for-the-following-claims-write-one-paragraph-identifying-the-logical-flaw-the-decrease-in-smoking-can-be-attributed-to-increased-restrictions-on-smoking-in-public/.

Copy