Descartes posits that the marked ice in a freezer can only be identified by depending on absolute certainty. Therefore, the individual must be capable of deducing that the ice is the result of frozen water. Locke proposes that there is no certainty in knowledge. Therefore, the identity of the ice will depend solely on observation.
Consider the example of maring ice in a freezer. How do we know that the water we placed in the freezer is the same thing as the ice we take out later? What would Descartes and Locke tell us about how we know the “thing” that is the water and the ice?
Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in philosophy. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.
Cite this page
Select a citation style:
References
Academic.Tips. (2022) 'Consider the example of maring ice in a freezer. How do we know that the water we placed in the freezer is the same thing as the ice we take out later? What would Descartes and Locke tell us about how we know the “thing” that is the water and the ice'. 9 December.
Reference
Academic.Tips. (2022, December 9). Consider the example of maring ice in a freezer. How do we know that the water we placed in the freezer is the same thing as the ice we take out later? What would Descartes and Locke tell us about how we know the “thing” that is the water and the ice? https://academic.tips/question/consider-the-example-of-maring-ice-in-a-freezer-how-do-we-know-that-the-water-we-placed-in-the-freezer-is-the-same-thing-as-the-ice-we-take-out-later-what-would-descartes-and-locke-tell-us-about-how/
References
Academic.Tips. 2022. "Consider the example of maring ice in a freezer. How do we know that the water we placed in the freezer is the same thing as the ice we take out later? What would Descartes and Locke tell us about how we know the “thing” that is the water and the ice?" December 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/consider-the-example-of-maring-ice-in-a-freezer-how-do-we-know-that-the-water-we-placed-in-the-freezer-is-the-same-thing-as-the-ice-we-take-out-later-what-would-descartes-and-locke-tell-us-about-how/.
1. Academic.Tips. "Consider the example of maring ice in a freezer. How do we know that the water we placed in the freezer is the same thing as the ice we take out later? What would Descartes and Locke tell us about how we know the “thing” that is the water and the ice?" December 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/consider-the-example-of-maring-ice-in-a-freezer-how-do-we-know-that-the-water-we-placed-in-the-freezer-is-the-same-thing-as-the-ice-we-take-out-later-what-would-descartes-and-locke-tell-us-about-how/.
Bibliography
Academic.Tips. "Consider the example of maring ice in a freezer. How do we know that the water we placed in the freezer is the same thing as the ice we take out later? What would Descartes and Locke tell us about how we know the “thing” that is the water and the ice?" December 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/consider-the-example-of-maring-ice-in-a-freezer-how-do-we-know-that-the-water-we-placed-in-the-freezer-is-the-same-thing-as-the-ice-we-take-out-later-what-would-descartes-and-locke-tell-us-about-how/.
Work Cited
"Consider the example of maring ice in a freezer. How do we know that the water we placed in the freezer is the same thing as the ice we take out later? What would Descartes and Locke tell us about how we know the “thing” that is the water and the ice?" Academic.Tips, 9 Dec. 2022, academic.tips/question/consider-the-example-of-maring-ice-in-a-freezer-how-do-we-know-that-the-water-we-placed-in-the-freezer-is-the-same-thing-as-the-ice-we-take-out-later-what-would-descartes-and-locke-tell-us-about-how/.
Copy