With regard to memories experienced after receiving an organ for a donor, Hume would argue that the self exists as a result of recorded sensory impressions. Therefore, sensory objects play a critical role in forming the self, which becomes embedded in the body. Descartes would argue that the act of thinking, which takes place in the body, is responsible for the transfer of memories to the recipient.
Consider cases in which someone has a heart transplant from an organ donor, and begins to experience feelings and emotions associated with that donor’s former life. What would two of the philosophers say about this phenomenon?
Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in philosophy. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.
Cite this page
Select a citation style:
References
Academic.Tips. (2022) 'Consider cases in which someone has a heart transplant from an organ donor, and begins to experience feelings and emotions associated with that donor’s former life. What would two of the philosophers say about this phenomenon'. 11 December.
Reference
Academic.Tips. (2022, December 11). Consider cases in which someone has a heart transplant from an organ donor, and begins to experience feelings and emotions associated with that donor’s former life. What would two of the philosophers say about this phenomenon? https://academic.tips/question/consider-cases-in-which-someone-has-a-heart-transplant-from-an-organ-donor-and-begins-to-experience-feelings-and-emotions-associated-with-that-donors-former-life-what-would-two-of-the-philo/
References
Academic.Tips. 2022. "Consider cases in which someone has a heart transplant from an organ donor, and begins to experience feelings and emotions associated with that donor’s former life. What would two of the philosophers say about this phenomenon?" December 11, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/consider-cases-in-which-someone-has-a-heart-transplant-from-an-organ-donor-and-begins-to-experience-feelings-and-emotions-associated-with-that-donors-former-life-what-would-two-of-the-philo/.
1. Academic.Tips. "Consider cases in which someone has a heart transplant from an organ donor, and begins to experience feelings and emotions associated with that donor’s former life. What would two of the philosophers say about this phenomenon?" December 11, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/consider-cases-in-which-someone-has-a-heart-transplant-from-an-organ-donor-and-begins-to-experience-feelings-and-emotions-associated-with-that-donors-former-life-what-would-two-of-the-philo/.
Bibliography
Academic.Tips. "Consider cases in which someone has a heart transplant from an organ donor, and begins to experience feelings and emotions associated with that donor’s former life. What would two of the philosophers say about this phenomenon?" December 11, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/consider-cases-in-which-someone-has-a-heart-transplant-from-an-organ-donor-and-begins-to-experience-feelings-and-emotions-associated-with-that-donors-former-life-what-would-two-of-the-philo/.
Work Cited
"Consider cases in which someone has a heart transplant from an organ donor, and begins to experience feelings and emotions associated with that donor’s former life. What would two of the philosophers say about this phenomenon?" Academic.Tips, 11 Dec. 2022, academic.tips/question/consider-cases-in-which-someone-has-a-heart-transplant-from-an-organ-donor-and-begins-to-experience-feelings-and-emotions-associated-with-that-donors-former-life-what-would-two-of-the-philo/.
Copy