Capital City High School has several spring athletic teams: a baseball team for men, a softball team for women and a track team for both women and men. The track team Betty Barton, a transgender woman brought suit seeking an injunction to be permitted to try out for the for the girls track team. Charles who goes by the name of “Charlene” Carson is a transgender woman. The case ultimately was decided by the United States Supreme Court. What results, and why?

At first sight, the fact that the previous transgender woman, Betty Barton, has set a precedent by receiving an injunction before the court decision regarding the participation in the girls’ track team suggests that the Supreme Court’s decision regarding Charles “Charlene” Carson should be in favor of the latter. However, scrutinizing the issue further, one will realize that the case under analysis implies the collision of the interests of Charles “Charlene” Carson and the rights of the female students on the track team. Specifically, the Supreme Court should consider the fact that Charles “Charlene” Carson holds an obvious physical advantage over the female students on the track team.

The need to balance out opportunities for both vulnerable groups, namely, female athletes and transgender male ones, should be seen as the main rationale for the specified choice. Indeed, encouraging transgender male athletes to compete in a team where they are grouped with other students based on sex creates premises for ensuring that trans athletes are provided with a fair chance to win while also respecting the rights of female athletes to compete in a fair setting. The suggested solution aligns with the principles of the 14th Amendment, as well as some of the recent solutions issued by the Supreme Court, such as the case of Connecticut Interscholastic Athletic Conference (CAIC) declaring that admitting male transgender athletes to all-female teams implied unfair competition.

Furthermore, the fact that the college provides a male track team option along with the female one, Charles “Charlene” Carson’s case, cannot be seen as the student being deprived of the right to compete. Thus, it is likely that the Court should decide that Carson should compete in the respective sex category (male). Therefore, although the recent legal case of male transgender students on women’s teams has been won by LGBTQ activists, it is possible that the Supreme Court considers the rational idea of sex-segregated sports as the premise not only for fairness but also for student safety.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in law. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2022) 'Capital City High School has several spring athletic teams: a baseball team for men, a softball team for women and a track team for both women and men. The track team Betty Barton, a transgender woman brought suit seeking an injunction to be permitted to try out for the for the girls track team. Charles who goes by the name of “Charlene” Carson is a transgender woman. The case ultimately was decided by the United States Supreme Court. What results, and why'. 9 October.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2022, October 9). Capital City High School has several spring athletic teams: a baseball team for men, a softball team for women and a track team for both women and men. The track team Betty Barton, a transgender woman brought suit seeking an injunction to be permitted to try out for the for the girls track team. Charles who goes by the name of “Charlene” Carson is a transgender woman. The case ultimately was decided by the United States Supreme Court. What results, and why? https://academic.tips/question/capital-city-high-school-has-several-spring-athletic-teams-a-baseball-team-for-men-a-softball-team-for-women-and-a-track-team-for-both-women-and-men-the-track-team-betty-barton-a-transgender-woman/

References

Academic.Tips. 2022. "Capital City High School has several spring athletic teams: a baseball team for men, a softball team for women and a track team for both women and men. The track team Betty Barton, a transgender woman brought suit seeking an injunction to be permitted to try out for the for the girls track team. Charles who goes by the name of “Charlene” Carson is a transgender woman. The case ultimately was decided by the United States Supreme Court. What results, and why?" October 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/capital-city-high-school-has-several-spring-athletic-teams-a-baseball-team-for-men-a-softball-team-for-women-and-a-track-team-for-both-women-and-men-the-track-team-betty-barton-a-transgender-woman/.

1. Academic.Tips. "Capital City High School has several spring athletic teams: a baseball team for men, a softball team for women and a track team for both women and men. The track team Betty Barton, a transgender woman brought suit seeking an injunction to be permitted to try out for the for the girls track team. Charles who goes by the name of “Charlene” Carson is a transgender woman. The case ultimately was decided by the United States Supreme Court. What results, and why?" October 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/capital-city-high-school-has-several-spring-athletic-teams-a-baseball-team-for-men-a-softball-team-for-women-and-a-track-team-for-both-women-and-men-the-track-team-betty-barton-a-transgender-woman/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "Capital City High School has several spring athletic teams: a baseball team for men, a softball team for women and a track team for both women and men. The track team Betty Barton, a transgender woman brought suit seeking an injunction to be permitted to try out for the for the girls track team. Charles who goes by the name of “Charlene” Carson is a transgender woman. The case ultimately was decided by the United States Supreme Court. What results, and why?" October 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/capital-city-high-school-has-several-spring-athletic-teams-a-baseball-team-for-men-a-softball-team-for-women-and-a-track-team-for-both-women-and-men-the-track-team-betty-barton-a-transgender-woman/.

Work Cited

"Capital City High School has several spring athletic teams: a baseball team for men, a softball team for women and a track team for both women and men. The track team Betty Barton, a transgender woman brought suit seeking an injunction to be permitted to try out for the for the girls track team. Charles who goes by the name of “Charlene” Carson is a transgender woman. The case ultimately was decided by the United States Supreme Court. What results, and why?" Academic.Tips, 9 Oct. 2022, academic.tips/question/capital-city-high-school-has-several-spring-athletic-teams-a-baseball-team-for-men-a-softball-team-for-women-and-a-track-team-for-both-women-and-men-the-track-team-betty-barton-a-transgender-woman/.

Copy