Bella is currently employed by KL Ltd, an insurance broker. KL Ltd operates a single office in New Town. Bella has a contract of employment with KL Ltd, which states that ‘On leaving the firm, employees are not permitted to work at any insurance broker within 25 miles of KL Ltd for a period of five years.’ Bella intends to resign from KL Ltd and establish her own insurance brokerage in New Town. Joe, a competitor to KL Ltd, is to buy the insurance broking business from KL Ltd. Explain, with justification, whether Bella is entitled to establish her own brokerage in New Town. Refer to one relevant case in support of your explanation. Explain, with justification, how Joe could prevent the directors of KL Ltd from establishing another insurance broking business in New Town.

Is Bella entitled to establish her own brokerage in New Town?

As per the terms of her employment contract, Bella is not supposed to work for another firm after leaving her employer KL Limited. Given this stipulation, she is not free from the limitations of the restrictive clauses on her employment contract, even if another party is buying her employer. The limitations imposed on her are reasonable and would be enforceable in a court of law because they only apply to businesses that are within a 25-mile radius and are only enforceable for five years. Therefore, Bella cannot claim that the restrictive terms are unreasonable, as was found in the Forster & Sons Ltd v. Suggett case, where a court of law ruled that a restrictive clause preventing an employee from working for a rival glass company was enforceable because it was only in effect for five years. The justification for enforcing such limitations could vary, but in the above-mentioned case, the resources and time used to train the employees were lauded as the main reason for the court’s decision. Therefore, the ruling was aimed at protecting the employer’s rights as should be the case with Bell and KL limited.

How Joe can Prevent KL Directors from starting Another Firm in New Town

Joe could prevent the directors of KL Limited from starting another insurance firm by getting an injunction from a court of law. Particularly, the case could be best resolved by obtaining a prohibitory injunction. This type of injunction is different from a mandatory injunction, which requires commitment from a party to complete an action that would remedy a negative undertaking. Injunctions are often obtained in unique cases where businesses are involved in a dispute. For example, there is extensive evidence showing its use in solving employment disputes to stop workers from breaching specific clauses in a contract, soliciting former clients to work in a new job, and disclosing trade secrets or confidential information.

Other instances where injunctions are used include situations where businesses want to enforce specific provisions of the law in a contract or when businesses want to prevent the publication of scandalous information. The failure to obey the injunction could be deemed to be contemptuous to the court and may attract stiff penalties, including imprisonment of offenders. This type of legal remedy is justifiable to use in the case involving Joe and KL Limited because injunctions are associated with contracts that have a negative undertaking, such as preventing a competitor from setting up a rival business. Therefore, an injunction may be introduced to make sure that the promise is not breached.

Answer by Academic.tip's expert
An answer to this question is provided by one of our experts who specializes in law. Let us know how much you liked it and give it a rating.

Cite this page

Select a citation style:

References

Academic.Tips. (2022) 'Bella is currently employed by KL Ltd, an insurance broker. KL Ltd operates a single office in New Town. Bella has a contract of employment with KL Ltd, which states that 'On leaving the firm, employees are not permitted to work at any insurance broker within 25 miles of KL Ltd for a period of five years.' Bella intends to resign from KL Ltd and establish her own insurance brokerage in New Town. Joe, a competitor to KL Ltd, is to buy the insurance broking business from KL Ltd. Explain, with justification, whether Bella is entitled to establish her own brokerage in New Town. Refer to one relevant case in support of your explanation. Explain, with justification, how Joe could prevent the directors of KL Ltd from establishing another insurance broking business in New Town'. 9 October.

Reference

Academic.Tips. (2022, October 9). Bella is currently employed by KL Ltd, an insurance broker. KL Ltd operates a single office in New Town. Bella has a contract of employment with KL Ltd, which states that 'On leaving the firm, employees are not permitted to work at any insurance broker within 25 miles of KL Ltd for a period of five years.' Bella intends to resign from KL Ltd and establish her own insurance brokerage in New Town. Joe, a competitor to KL Ltd, is to buy the insurance broking business from KL Ltd. Explain, with justification, whether Bella is entitled to establish her own brokerage in New Town. Refer to one relevant case in support of your explanation. Explain, with justification, how Joe could prevent the directors of KL Ltd from establishing another insurance broking business in New Town. https://academic.tips/question/bella-is-currently-employed-by-kl-ltd-an-insurance-broker-kl-ltd-operates-a-single-office-in-new-town-bella-has-a-contract-of-employment-with-kl-ltd-which-states-that-on-leaving-the-firm-employ/

References

Academic.Tips. 2022. "Bella is currently employed by KL Ltd, an insurance broker. KL Ltd operates a single office in New Town. Bella has a contract of employment with KL Ltd, which states that 'On leaving the firm, employees are not permitted to work at any insurance broker within 25 miles of KL Ltd for a period of five years.' Bella intends to resign from KL Ltd and establish her own insurance brokerage in New Town. Joe, a competitor to KL Ltd, is to buy the insurance broking business from KL Ltd. Explain, with justification, whether Bella is entitled to establish her own brokerage in New Town. Refer to one relevant case in support of your explanation. Explain, with justification, how Joe could prevent the directors of KL Ltd from establishing another insurance broking business in New Town." October 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/bella-is-currently-employed-by-kl-ltd-an-insurance-broker-kl-ltd-operates-a-single-office-in-new-town-bella-has-a-contract-of-employment-with-kl-ltd-which-states-that-on-leaving-the-firm-employ/.

1. Academic.Tips. "Bella is currently employed by KL Ltd, an insurance broker. KL Ltd operates a single office in New Town. Bella has a contract of employment with KL Ltd, which states that 'On leaving the firm, employees are not permitted to work at any insurance broker within 25 miles of KL Ltd for a period of five years.' Bella intends to resign from KL Ltd and establish her own insurance brokerage in New Town. Joe, a competitor to KL Ltd, is to buy the insurance broking business from KL Ltd. Explain, with justification, whether Bella is entitled to establish her own brokerage in New Town. Refer to one relevant case in support of your explanation. Explain, with justification, how Joe could prevent the directors of KL Ltd from establishing another insurance broking business in New Town." October 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/bella-is-currently-employed-by-kl-ltd-an-insurance-broker-kl-ltd-operates-a-single-office-in-new-town-bella-has-a-contract-of-employment-with-kl-ltd-which-states-that-on-leaving-the-firm-employ/.


Bibliography


Academic.Tips. "Bella is currently employed by KL Ltd, an insurance broker. KL Ltd operates a single office in New Town. Bella has a contract of employment with KL Ltd, which states that 'On leaving the firm, employees are not permitted to work at any insurance broker within 25 miles of KL Ltd for a period of five years.' Bella intends to resign from KL Ltd and establish her own insurance brokerage in New Town. Joe, a competitor to KL Ltd, is to buy the insurance broking business from KL Ltd. Explain, with justification, whether Bella is entitled to establish her own brokerage in New Town. Refer to one relevant case in support of your explanation. Explain, with justification, how Joe could prevent the directors of KL Ltd from establishing another insurance broking business in New Town." October 9, 2022. https://academic.tips/question/bella-is-currently-employed-by-kl-ltd-an-insurance-broker-kl-ltd-operates-a-single-office-in-new-town-bella-has-a-contract-of-employment-with-kl-ltd-which-states-that-on-leaving-the-firm-employ/.

Work Cited

"Bella is currently employed by KL Ltd, an insurance broker. KL Ltd operates a single office in New Town. Bella has a contract of employment with KL Ltd, which states that 'On leaving the firm, employees are not permitted to work at any insurance broker within 25 miles of KL Ltd for a period of five years.' Bella intends to resign from KL Ltd and establish her own insurance brokerage in New Town. Joe, a competitor to KL Ltd, is to buy the insurance broking business from KL Ltd. Explain, with justification, whether Bella is entitled to establish her own brokerage in New Town. Refer to one relevant case in support of your explanation. Explain, with justification, how Joe could prevent the directors of KL Ltd from establishing another insurance broking business in New Town." Academic.Tips, 9 Oct. 2022, academic.tips/question/bella-is-currently-employed-by-kl-ltd-an-insurance-broker-kl-ltd-operates-a-single-office-in-new-town-bella-has-a-contract-of-employment-with-kl-ltd-which-states-that-on-leaving-the-firm-employ/.

Copy